[original discussion]Ko9 wrote:
I think the forum should have a actual agreed on policy when it comes to screenshotting discord/twitch/youtube/whatever when it comes to Matt but also to if we show names or profile pictures of these people. I have done it so badly, incorrectly and emotionally so I cannot be mister moralman here. But I would like to have at least some forum member commenting on this.
This is a good topic to bring up, especially since we have to resort to scouring these platforms more and more for information now that Mat has vacated the forum.
IMO the policy should be that if the platform in question is clearly public, there is no special need to block out names or avatars. This would include YouTube comments/chat, Twitch chats, tweets, and public Facebook conversations. If you're posting on any of these platforms you must accept the responsibilty that all of that stuff is public, full stop. Private things like DMs on the other hand should obviously be posted under careful discretion so that things are not being posted against Mat's wishes or anything.
Discord is weird in my eyes because on the one hand, invite links to servers are typically pretty public, but they are still invite links. As in, you have to be invited to join a Discord server in every case. Therefore I tend to think of Discord as a private platform of sorts, and would advocate for blocking out user info for Discord messages to be safe. In the case of Mat's server, it would not be hard to join his server and find the messages that were posted by text searching, but it still should not be treated as open as something like a YT comment thread would be.